While writing
my journal after teaching yesterday, I had a revelation that I felt may be relevant
to more than just me so I thought I would share.
I was
talking to my class about confidence, and doing things half heartedly, the
girls who are lacking in a little confidence can often be seen marking, rather
than risk being wrong and doing it full out incorrectly, they do it half-heartedly
thinking that no one will notice because it’s small. I keep saying to them
“If you’re marking because you’re scared of being
wrong, you’re not doing it correctly anyway, you’re automatically wrong without
giving yourself a chance.”
I was
trying to get across to them that they are taking away their opportunity to be
right!! (or their opportunity to improve by getting it wrong and learning from
it.)
And then I realised,
I often take away my opportunity to be right, or to improve by avoiding situations
or not doing anything at all. This fear of making mistakes can often hold us
back.
This then
took me back to some things I had reviewed in the reader about experience,
reflection and learning, John Dewey felt
“…the
quality of the education was linked to the level of engagement with, and
consciousness of the experience”
If we are
not engaging with the experience, by marking instead of dancing, thinking in
our heads but not blogging, knowing how to improve our workplace but not
communicating it, all for fear of being wrong or reprimanded then we have no opportunity
to improve ourselves or our situation.
In order to
learn we have to take risks, my Mum always says to me “If you don’t try… you’ll
never know!” and this is exactly what I was trying to say when I was teaching. And
something I need to keep in my own mind more often.
In the
environment of a dance studio I find it easy to take risks, to try and fail and
use that opportunity to improve, but in every other area of my life, I see
trying and failing as a negative. Maybe it’s time I changed that perspective.
In Peter
Honey and Alan Mumford’s model inspired by Kolb’s learning cycle they identify
four stages of learning
- Having an experience
- Reviewing the experience
- Concluding from the experience
- Planning the next step
If we are
avoiding experiences (in case we fail) then we have nothing to review or
reflect upon, and while we may think we know what will happen we have nothing
concrete to go from and so we stay in the same place, situation or mindset that
we had previously. (You could call that failure in itself?)
In order to
be reflective we have to do something to reflect upon, something that matters,
an action or an attempt, and then in reflecting upon this we can make decisions
about the success of that experience and use this to plan, move on and grow.
I liked Adesola’s
post about getting messy…
“Hopefully
you are well into everything, possibly getting acquainted with the feeling of
‘not knowing’, which comes before that light-bulb moment as things click into
place. I think the biggest thing to check at this point is that you are ‘in
it’.”
We have to
be “in it” whether we know what we are doing or not, we have to keep trying and
engaging, then we can get it wrong, reflect and learn or as Adesola says have a
“light bulb moment” and succeed. Either way it’s a positive thing, through not
trying we are failing anyway, so what is there to be afraid of?
References.
Adesola
Akinleye. Blog, 08/03/2012
Dewey
J. 1916
Honey
1982, Honey and Mumford 1983
WBS 3730, Reader 2. The Reflective Practitioner 2011/2012
Hi Danni
ReplyDeleteThis is so true and something I too am guilty of! I have been told for years to "let myself go"! It's something I also try to teach in my classes and yet something I am STILL guilty of today!
I think my problem in general is that I am an 'over thinker'. This year for me is all about trying to overcome this. I have committed to several things that I have wanted to do of for years but always found an excuse not to! (One being...this course!)
It is a constant battle, I think having a dance background is a huge contributor to this problem. We have technique drilled into us for years and then the industry is so cut-throat that we feel the need to be perfect to get ahead.
I am trying to approach all aspects of my life with a more confident attitude for example I have committed to learning to drive! I spent six years on cruise ships so I told myself "I don't really need to learn", then it was "I can't really afford it' and the truth is the idea of driving has always made me nervous!! The first few lessons were scary but now I am really enjoying it! I'll let you know when I pass my test!! Silly example, I know but relevant I think!
Good luck!!
Kelly xx
Thanks for this Danni. Yes I put up a blog conveyance, bugbears and rewards - it carries on this thinking about what it takes to allow us to develop - to improve perhaps. From personal experience, I think that rewards are also a part of the learning process in the real world as are actually outlining things that are challenges or are not going well. Your blog examines how you might do this in practice. In your example, giving your class a chance to experience something - worts and all- was a part of the experience. This was something that came up at the conference I recently went to about creative businesses - the head of these businesses all said you needed to be able to make mistakes! It is a part of the learning process.
ReplyDelete